I have collected some pieces there as I said to you. I am sure I photocopied much more than you would want. Should I take you through them?
Evan Walker
I have collected some pieces there as I said to you. I am sure I photocopied much more than you would want. Should I take you through them?
Des Smith
What we’ve done, and I’ll give this to you and Judy, I put together some notes about this idea, I don’t know whether Bruce explained to you what the general thrust of it is?
Bruce Allen
Only very briefly.
Des
Yeah ok. Because the idea, or the intention of the work, is to talk to architects from, largely from the ‘60s and ‘70s. ‘Cause I graduated in the late ‘70s, and I was fortunate enough to work for Kevin Borland, Max May, and some other interesting people. And I met guys like Bruce. I met Daryl [Jackson] quite a lot, and I hadn’t really met you in the office. But that period was really important, certainly in Victorian architecture, and probably Australian.
Evan
Where was Jackson Walker located during those times?
Des
The times that I probably spoke to Daryl [Jackson] was when the office was in Little Bourke Street. And the office before that was in East Melbourne, was it?
Evan
Yes, it was.
Jonathan Gardiner
Ah, there was the factory in Collingwood.
Des
Ah, the one in Collingwood yeah. Because Max [May] was in Collingwood. Kevin [Borland] was in Collingwood.
Evan
That was Fitzroy Place.
Des
Ah yeah, that’s where Daryl [Jackson] was. But prior to that was Hotham Street?
Evan
It was the Fitwell Shoe company that was there [Fitzroy Place], but I was involved in politics at that time.
Des
And the intention was that we would just have chats with people about their life in architecture, and life in general.
Evan
Yeah, excellent thing to do.
Jonathan
One of the things that drove the conversation was - we were at an Awards, an Architectural Awards night a couple of years ago, and Des and I were having a drink and saying various commentary about buildings that had won the Awards that year, and the most interesting building in our view was the enduring 25 year Award, that was won by Graeme Gunn for the Plumbers and Gasfitters building.
Judy
Little Gem we used to call it.
Jonathan
But what was interesting about our observation of the audience was that most of them didn’t understand it because they looked at it through today’s lens. They hadn’t understood what it meant when it was being done, and in fact, our conversation grew to the point that most of the people in the room didn’t understand the shoulders that they were standing on. And in fact Des and I feel that we don’t understand the shoulders we stand on either, but at least know we’re ‘standing on shoulders’. A lot of the people don’t even understand that they’re part of an outcome of a broader cultural movement, and some buildings shouldn’t be assessed purely on ‘do you like it or not’. It should be, what was it doing, why was it done, what was the context and culture in which it was done, that actually makes it able to now practice in the city.
Evan
Well that’s a really interesting conversation that we can have. How many have you done so far?
Des
You’re it.
Jonathan
We spoke to Graeme Gunn - but we spoke to him about the idea. But he thought we were interviewing him, so he cleared his throat, and then we said, “No we just want to have a chat”. And we do want it to be a bit of a chat, really.
Bruce
One of the things that I’ve mentioned is that, in your time as a politician you were still acting as an architect, because a lot of the time you were influencing what architect got what public building.
Evan
That’s true.
Bruce
And therefore, your influence was carried forward in that process as well.
Evan
Yeah. No, I would accept that as what we were doing. To do what we were doing, in the context of what Daryl was doing, we parted company a little. Although he agreed with me that the full spectrum of what we were doing was legitimate architecture. And it’s true that architects used to come to talk to us. Really to talk about architecture, and not its causing. It was very easy to get caught up in conversations that were irrelevant, and often building small stuff as we did, or simple stuff. That’s where architects tended to get caught up. They expressed themselves quite clearly. They’d find themselves down lanes that have no real context. They’d get frustrated. The sort of work that Daryl and I were doing jointly, and near the end a little bit separately because I took on working on committees. I’ll show you a Who’s Who entry and you can see what I am doing is chairing committees and being as involved as a client. Seems odd, but I was transferring to a start of.... What I should, I should stop giving you the whole world....
Judy
What I think you’re trying to say Evan is this - you were involved more with an input into a community. I mean your work at Bunning Girls High School, and your involvement with education, was particularly important at that time, wasn’t it? I think it is really important for you guys to know what kind of world it was, being right back in ’69 permanently was an amazing time. I mean you remember it [gestures to Bruce], you were a student during that time.
Evan
Well, he was the number one employee.
Bruce
That sounds even better than the first employee.
Save Collins Street
↺Jonathan
You’re right though, I think the comment is that building a city requires more than drawing buildings. And it requires influence and advocacy at a whole range of levels, of which the pen is almost, it’s not quite the final one - that’s the pouring of the concrete or what have you - but the pen is almost the last part of the process, not the beginning of the process, so the context is fantastic. That is what we would like to talk about.
Bruce
What sort of role did the Collins Street fight play in guiding you into politics?
Evan
I have used that to explain what occurred
Judy
Well the National Bank was under threat, wasn’t it? On Collins St?
Evan
Yes.
Judy
And it was going to be demolished and you had been agitating for quite some time. Having been in North American, having lived in Toronto, and witness a city that had pretty well destroyed its heart - um, it’s old buildings, it’s old red brick buildings - Evan came back and realised how precious our built environment was and how much we had lost during that period of time when he was overseas, which was 8 years or so, and two markets had gone and you know. I can remember Evan telling me about this. I was amazed by this wonderful city that was here.
Jonathan
Still intact?
Judy
Still intact, largely intact.
Evan
Yes, we had lost a few, though.
Judy
But we had lost the markets - Princes and Western Markets - and some of the buildings were coming down, and anyway... So you began. He was very much involved with worked for the National Trust and others, and when the... I mean there was a great ethos of what was old was not as valuable as what was new. And I think every community and culture goes through that. So when the national bank was going to be demolished, Evan put an ad in the paper, on an October night.
Evan
In ’76.
Judy
Yes, ’76 it was, and said “Anybody interested in saving Collins Street” which was rather audacious, “Come to 21 Hilder Crescent”. And we thought maybe 6 people would show up. Well there were hundreds of people.
Evan
Judy tends to exaggerate the numbers.
Judy
No, no. It was amazing, we had people...
Evan
It was a big house and it was overflowing, flowing out the door.
Judy
They were flowing out the door. I mean the dining room and the living room, you know, and we didn’t have a back room at that point. It was just full of wet people ‘cause it was a pouring night. All shapes and sizes. All political colours, whatever, and they were all there because they loved Collins Street. They loved their city.
Evan
It attached itself, the movement, sort of associated itself with the National Trust, and they had a program going called ‘Save’. It wasn’t called ‘Save Collins Street’, we were doing that. It was the Commercial Bank tower that was under threat.
Judy
But they felt that it was a very hopeless case because...
Evan
They were going to do their best to ... [help?]
Judy
But he didn’t want to get political, Warrick, at that stage. He didn’t want to put ...
Jonathan
Sorry, Warrick?
Judy
Warrick Forage, he was with the National Trust at that point. Do you remember? And it was the Lindsay ... was Bolte still in government at that point?
Evan
No, it was Dick Hamer. Mitchell helped a bit ‘cause he was sensitive.
Judy
But planning was really to do with Melbourne City Council. That was your problem.
Evan
Well, it still is.
Judy
Ha, I know dear.
Jonathan
Still the problem, or still the authority?
Judy
Except for the ??? who took planning powers away from them. But it was the Melbourne City Council that was full of developers at that time. Do you remember that? So out of that movement of people, that met every week at our house, grew a rather big gang. We got something like - I don’t know how many thousands of signatures. People up and down Collins Street came and signed. And then we/Evan organised the march, and we made these huge, wonderful sticks that we all marched with, you know, ‘Save our Collins Street’, and we had big banners and we marched them down Collins Street. I mean looking back it was a very naive thing to do, but it was ... it attracted a lot of attention.
Jonathan
Well it worked!
Judy
It certainly worked. The National Bank was saved.
Evan
It drew out an interesting crowd. Some commitments that you wouldn’t have expected.
Jonathan
Right.
Evan
And then, people like and as old at the Murphys - John and Phyllis Murphy.
Jonathan
Yes.
Evan
And as young as ...
Judy
Julie Eisenberg.
Evan
From Melbourne University - Julie Eisenberg and Hank Koning?
Judy
Who were still students.
Evan
Who had practiced in Los Angeles, and had won prizes in the American scene. It was important to recognise that these people were a solid base, and they... Some of the city councillors joined the fray. Trevor Huggard.
Judy
John Mitchell, was it?
Evan
John Mitchell was a strong supporter. [Doorbell rings.]
Des
That’ll be Graeme.
Des
So did the ‘Save Collins Street Movement’ start at your house?
Evan
Yes, in October 1976.
Des
And did you invent the name?
Evan
Yes.
Des
And which bank are you talking about - the one on Collins and Elizabeth or the William and Collins?
Evan
In the block ... there were three banks between Elizabeth Street and Swanston street.
Des
Yeah.
Evan
That’s the main block of the city, built around Collins ... [Graeme Gunn arrives.]
Evan
Hello Graeme. You made it.
Graeme Gunn
Yeah, now which day is it?
Judy
Coffee, tea?
Des
For the CIA who are listening to this, Graeme Gunn has just appeared.
Evan
You haven’t been here before have you?
Graeme
No, this is the Labor Party headquarters?
Jonathan
No, it’s the Save Collins Street headquarters.
Evan
We are just dealing with the Collins Street... what’s it called?
Judy
‘Collins Street Defence Movement’.
Des
Was it called ‘Save Collins Street’?
Evan
No.
Evan
But I think the National Trust had a bumper sticker that said something like that.
Des
Oh, is that where it came from?
Judy
‘Collins Street Defence Movement’ - and it was a joint decision. The first out of that huge group. A little committee was formed, of about 20 people, and it was the committee who voted. And it was their idea [the name]. I don’t think Evan would have thought that the Collins Street Defence Movement was worth defending, but they thought it was a great name and so that was it, do you remember? It was a democratic vote.
Jonathan
It was just after the Vietnam war wasn’t it?
Judy
Yeah, I know, I know.
Jonathan
Defence movements have a certain connotation.
Judy
I know, everyone thought they’d want ‘Save Our Collins Street’ or something, but no, they wanted it. So it was the group actually that decided.
Des
Were you part of it Graeme? JUDY and
Graeme
No.
Evan
He was in the ... he was an architect who was sensitive to the city of Melbourne and ...
Graeme
We’d been through the Brookes Crescent, through the Housing Commission.
Evan
Yes, that’s right.
Des
In Fitzroy?
Graeme
Ah yeah. But that was about 1965 or ’67.
Des
Ah, ok. So ten years prior?
Graeme
Probably.
Evan
Yes, that’s about right. We’ve got it well documented.
Graeme
Have you?
Evan
Well we’ve got the story so far, a kind of a narrative.
Graeme
Yeah, ‘cause a lot of that came out of the Institute of Architects, the public service committee they had there.
Evan
Yes.
Graeme
Andrew, Daryl and I were on the council. Andrew McCutcheon. That’s right.
Evan
We were a more inclusive show, you’re quite right. Then the housing issue in North Fitzroy took some of the people you’d been trusting, and multiplied it into a pretty big membership.
Graeme
And you’d have had lawyers?
Evan
Yes.
Graeme
Yeah, you see. We weren’t that smart.
Des
So the Collin Street Defence Movement was that against developers, or the State Government, or the Melbourne City Council in a sense?
Evan
Who was the enemy?
Des
In a sense, yeah. Or was it sort of building by building really?
Graeme
Well I ... that’d be after I. M. Pei did Collins St, and I remember we had been on the council. It was Les Perrot who asked us to dinner at the Melbourne Club - which was a first for me.
Des
When you say council, do you mean Institute Council or?
Graeme
No, no. The ‘suburbists’. I don’t think all the councillors attended.
Des
But like the Institute Council, or the Melbourne City Council?
Graeme
Institute Council - to meet with I. M. Pei. Who was his offsider? Jeff Cobb?
Evan
Yeah....
Graeme
A younger guy, anyway. So we met at the Melbourne Club for dinner, and I had never been to the Melbourne Club before. So it was quite a good thing to get there, but then I remember having an argument with Paine[?] about what he’d done, and what he’d pulled out, and what he had put up. I think we were more fervently religious about the thing than rational.
Jonathan
Hasn’t changed has it?
Des
But then I think the fact that people were fervent must have been important as well, ‘cause I guess the developers were assuming that people didn’t really care?
Graeme
Yeah, it’s true, but probably there were well entrenched people in Melbourne City Council. So if you look at some of those people then that were mayors, like Bernard Evans, and Meldrum [from Meldrum Burrows].
Des
We’re talking architects aren’t we.
Graeme
They were architects.
Evan
No they weren’t, they were grandfather clocks.
Graeme
But that was ... the Institute was a bit like that then, wasn’t it? Because they had the four major players, the four major firms in Melbourne who really controlled the whole thing. It was just that Robin Boyd and Peter Mcintyre had come in. But other than that, it was people like Perrot Lyon Matheison, Spowers, and Yuncken Freeman, Bates Smart - Ozie [Osborne McCutcheon] had gone by then, though - Spowers were another... They were manipulating the whole practice issues throughout the ...
Judy
And then there was the night when all you young bucks decided you were going to reform the Institute.
Graeme
Yeah, we had a run at it. But then Robin Boyd was there, and so was Peter [MacIntyre]. And Peter was the activist with us on the Housing Commission then. We used to go up and see Jack Gaskin, who was the head ...
Evan
Of the Housing Commission.
Graeme
Yeah. And have all these talks, “No boys, no, no, just, you don’t understand”. All that sort of response. So that probably got us a bit agitated. And then they brought across Sharpie from Western Australia, who was an Englishman. Jack, what was his name? Harkin? But he was an educated person and had a degree of sensitivity, and he was brought in to somehow mediate everything. But it didn’t work out. He couldn’t get around Jack [Gaskin] so it ended up being this battle around this little place called Brookes Crescent. A little street. And that’s when they lost it.
Des
So the Brookes Crescent battle was lost was it?
Graeme
No, they won that.
Des
That’s that little, tiny group of workers cottages which make a kind of street. But that, you said that was ten years before the Collins Street movement?
Graeme
Yeah, Collins street was later. They were more sophisticated because they actually tabulated everything.
Evan
It was more focused, and it clearly represented something that the public wanted dearly. The ad that we put in the newspaper had an electric effect. People were... we were just saying as you came in... we held the first meeting at our house, and a big crowd turned up. And formed themselves into committees, and John Murphy made some of the nicest hand cards...
Judy
Placards, that we marched up and down Collins Street with.
Jonathan
John Murphy’s special ....
Judy
Oh, they were beautifully done. We had them for years - oh really, nearly until we moved out of Hilder Crescent - we had these beautifully designed placards - circular ones, you know ‘Save our Collins Street’. ‘Collins Street Defence Movement’. We had a lot of fun. We were also involved in Hawthorn by then, because the whole thing was happening not just in Collins Street, but was happening right throughout the suburbs. And in Hawthorn we joined a fellow named McInly Willson who was a liberal - member of the liberal party - because he didn’t want the trees in Barkly Street pulled down. So, ah, we, Evan and I and a few other people got together with him and we formed the Hawthorn Residents Association. And we put Betty Marginson up - Ray Marginson’s wife - up for Mayor. We got rid of the council eventually. Bill Nankerville was a member who became a councillor. It really changed, and it was an electric change. Once you changed the people in the council then the whole dynamic changed, and that needed to happen at the [Melbourne] City Council too.
Graeme
It’s those rabid Canadians coming over here.
Judy
Now now, I wasn’t the one leading it, I was just following it... But you see it was that overseas experience that we started off with that became ... you came back and thought, “things don’t have to go the same way that they’ve gone elsewhere”.
Evan
It’s not without precedent. Jack Gaskin came through Toronto on his way to London, and he was looking at very bad examples of inner urban housing, and I got a note... we had people here in Melbourne watching. Particularly at the time in North Fitzroy and the housing board...
Judy
The Housing Commission stuff?
Evan
It was... we weren’t on a committee or anything, but Jack Gaskin and his offsider from the Housing Commission turned up in Toronto and I had... ahhh .... tour around Toronto. Which they did, and then we sat down and watched, and then when it was over they said, “That’s all very well but we, we have much bigger problems”. They had just built the South Melbourne tower.
Jonathan
Park Tower?
Evan
And ah, Jack was rather, he must have had somebody brief him because he had a pretty offhand approach to it. He said, “They had solved the slum housing problem by building.... they defined the problem quite well in Toronto, but got stuck on the solution... they were building high rise housing not unlike what was happening here.”. Jack Gaskin murmured as we were going to our next appointment “No need to worry about this. This stuff- we’ve been doing it for years”.
Judy
Yeah. I remember how embarrassed you were after he left. He didn’t ask any questions!
Evan
I had to debrief the key housing people in Toronto about it.
Graeme
Oh I see, well at least you met him, over there. ‘Cause they were a breed weren’t they? There was ah... who was the head of the public works department? It was, um ...
Evan
Swan.
Graeme
No, no, not public works. Waterworks.
Evan
Croxford.
Graeme
They were sort of regal.
Judy
Oh. King Pin.
Des
And was this, Gasket? Is that his name? Was he an architect?
Graeme
No.
Jonathan
He was an engineer wasn’t he? I thought he was just really keen to work out how he could get precast thirty storeys.
Graeme
I think he might have started on drainage.
Judy
Hahah. He started on drains.
Des
So he almost definitely wasn’t an architect?
Evan
No.
Des
‘Cause I’m interested in, this is what we were hoping would happen - these conversations that just wander off. At that point were they saying that housing was a social issue, an architectural issue, or a ‘let’s just make it all go away and stack these people in boxes and we don’t have to worry about it’ engineering solution?
Graeme
Oh, well it was slums, and then...
Evan
Slums. Yeah.
Graeme
And then Perrot came back - Perrot senior - came back from overseas, and said this is the way to go.
Des
This isn’t Les [Perrot]? This is Les’ father is it?
Evan
Well, he was Les too.
Des
Ah, right ok.
Evan
It is a bit confusing, but it’s Les senior.
Graeme
It could have been Corbusier’s fault, actually.
Des
Well that was my next question - were they saying the Corb model is the one to follow, or was it someone else?
Jonathan
The Radiant City.
Evan
Yes, it was .... [indecipherable]
Judy
Well, it was sort of a social welfare issue too, because there was a movement in the welfare field, which was to clear slums. I mean you think of Bethnal Green in London and what was happening there, and how they ... ‘Cause I did my training - and saw just at the end of that - and saw the consequences that the break up of these communities had on people. They became socially isolated, and they’d be ... suicide rates would go up, and then drugs went up, and alcohol and that sort of thing. And it was just at the end of that because they had no idea. They thought once you’d cleaned up these neighbourhoods everything would be ok. And it never was. It got worse.
Evan
Judy is a social worker.
Des
Right. I was going to ask what you did.
Bruce
I think they were very proud of their precast technology, too. And I remember them coming to speak to students. They would tell us about the diary farmer in Werribee who invented precast concrete to build a diary, and they had used that technology. And then they built this whooping big factory at Holmesglen, and the tail starts to wag the dog.
Jonathan
And then they had to use the factory to do all sorts of things - like public conveniences, and park fences, and precast pebble mix...
Evan
To be fair the actual structure of those high rise housing blocks was very clever. Robin Boyd used to write admiringly about the concrete housing project.
Graeme
He awarded the South Melbourne building [Park Tower] one of the awards, even.
Judy
That’s right.
Graeme
And we had a commission at the end, in it’s demise - Homesglen - to do single level housing. What are we going to do with these panels? So we, it was a concrete core bathroom kitchen and then a ring beam and panels, and ah, they were done. We did some prototypes actually.
Evan
They were the elements that made the 36-storey building in South Melbourne. 36 or 40 or something.
Graeme
You can see it from here.
Judy
Wasn’t it Bill Brown who invented it? The engineer who lived in Hawthorn?
Evan
Yeah, he lived in Hawthorn.
Judy
Yes, he was very proud of his...
Evan
Stack of Cards.
Judy
Yeah, I remember talking about it.
Evan
Yeah, that was what I was trying to explain. It was that he had some cause, some cause to be proud, solve a problem that needed to be solved.
Judy
But mums wanted to look after their children, you know. 20 storeys down they’re looking a tiny little pocket handkerchief. It just didn’t work.
Evan
Mums were letting baskets down the 20 or so floors to the kids with their afternoon milk and fruit or whatever it is.
Judy
Actually you might be interested in talking to Andy [Andrew] McCutcheon at some stage, too.
Des
He’s on our list.
Judy
Is he? ‘Cause he and Viv moved into Die? street - into the Housing Commission there for a while. When I first met them, and when Evan went overseas, Viv and Andrew moved into there. He was the minister then. He’d done his architecture and then he’d done his theology.
Des
You mean a real minister?
Judy
Yes, a real minister yes. Not a political one. He’s done lots of things Andrew. He’s away at the moment. But he moved in and lived amongst... Viv was a trained social worker, so they can give you that Housing Commission and what happened there in the inner city because he formed a relationship with three other Pastors, or an Anglican. He was in the Methodist church in that time, and then there was a Catholic fellow. And anyway they tried to get some stuff going, but that’s another story.
Jonathan
So were the slums really bad?
Evan
The?
Des
Where the Park Tower one is, or the ones in Fitzroy? Was the housing really bad in your memory?
Evan
Who knows, [that’s] the question? Nowhere near as bad as it was several years ago.
Graeme
There’d be plenty of information on it, but I’d imagine also that they were badly serviced. And...
Des
So they would have been neglected?
Graeme
They would have been neglected, yes. It must have been a wonderful place for kids.
Judy
Hmm...
Jonathan
You hear sort of the horror story of how bad they were, written as contemporary accounts from the angle of, “we need to knock them down and do something better”, so you hear that sort of one act per street type stuff. But whether or not they were actually...
Des
The question is interesting, ‘cause then there were whole lots of those areas that weren’t pushed over - like near Park Towers - which were great houses.
Graeme
Or in Richmond. These are now $800,000. [Oh how times have changed.]
Bruce
One of the transition points must have been when you did City Edge, ‘cause that land was accumulated by the Housing Commission.
Evan
Quite right. It was a real breakthrough because it gave rise to a clever sort of grouping of various consultants. They were a good team. The architects included Jackson and Walker, and we were given the opportunity to lead by way of advising the Public Works. And they got quite excited about doing City Edge in the way it should be done. And we chose good architects - we did it ourselves.
Des
Was that a private commission? Or was that public work?
Graeme
I think Merchant Builders won the bid, didn’t they?
Evan
Yes that sounds right.
Graeme
They put it together.
Evan
David Yencken, was a very important ...
Graeme
Kevin Greenhatch had to start it with them.
Evan
Do you know Kevin Greenhatch?
Des
Yeah. Was Kevin at Merchants, was he?
Jonathan
Yes.
Des
I remember Kevin Greenhatch from when I was at Max May’s office. Kevin used to drop in every now and again.
Evan
Yeah, that’s the era. In Collingwood. Max May’s office was very close to our office.
Des
Yeah, it was too.
Evan
But you’re right, the person who really put it together, by co-ordinating the work of the various professionals, was David Yencken.
Des
And when is City Edge? Is that in the ‘70s? Mid ‘70s?
Evan
Yeah, right in the heart.
Jonathan
And that also won an award, didn’t it?
Graeme
Yeah, it was the only thing of its kind...
Jonathan
It was extraordinary.
Graeme
.... of reasonably high density housing, as distinct from the towers.
Evan
And it’s a simple, simple job. It was to turn tall buildings into... without increasing the cost of density, we designed 5-storeys without the walkway. Really quite... sort of housing we hadn’t had before in Melbourne.
Des
And what was the model for it? Architecturally where did those ideas come from?
Evan
Partly from the Thames in London, and ah, memory is a fickle thing. I’ve lost it.
Graeme
Was that the Span?
Evan
What? They were a construction outfit.
Graeme
But it was an architect though...
Des
So it was British model, not a ..?
Graeme
Well that might have been the default. Well they had a density and a DFA I suppose, so that was how you designed within ... Probably the architect might have actually...
Des
Ah yeah, I was just...
Jonathan
It could well have been a unique idea.
Des
Ah, yeah. That was kinda my question. Did it come out of a particular problem and a particular way of thinking that might have been localised?
Evan
Yes.
Graeme
But it’s such a unique site that it probably did generate its own resolution.
Des
But again, David Yencken is crucial to it, ‘cause he spots the possibility? Is that what happened?
Graeme
No. I think Greenhatch would have dug it up, offered it to David, cause that’s what Greenhatch was doing. He was putting things together all the time.
Jonathan
He’s a dealer.
Des
But Kevin’s an architect isn’t he?
Jonathan
Yeah, he was an architect.
Bruce
But it wasn’t originally a site clearance though. The site was accumulated by government intervention. And I can’t understand how the switch then occurred with the government accumulating it and then handing it to a private developer.
Graeme
Ahh, well they do that. They still do that. They just get expressions of interest and go into bidding.
Jonathan
I think Tract do it now.
Graeme
It’s very common.
Evan
That work, that era, drove out into the public works. We’re the construction outfit, and it was a very early joint project - that’s what these days it’s called. But they, they shouted they could - the Public Works shouted that they were capable of being briefed on densities and envelopes like that, that they’d never seen before. It was right in the middle of the ‘70s. Andrew [McCutcheon] and I went travelling to Europe with Rob Hampton[?]. There was a whole generation that, distant from now - trying to think of the key. There was an amazing ... just trying to think of something. We brought back a fair bit of stuff that the English architects had been doing.
Judy
Something Newtowns?
Jonathan
Millton Keynes?
Graeme
And Andrew started his planning practice then.
Evan
Andrew was in business for a short while.
Des
This is Andrew McCutcheon?
Graeme
Yes. So he was on that team.
Judy
Or joined his father’s firm and started what was it called? Plan Urb?
Jonathan
Urbis?
Graeme
No.
Judy
What was it??
Evan
His dad wasn’t too pleased. His father [Osborne McCutcheon] was still active.
Judy
What do you mean, “not too pleased”, he joined his father’s firm?
Graeme
As a planner though, not as an architect.
Des
Is this the same McCutcheon?
Judy
Yeah, yeah.
Des
I’d never stuck that together before
Judy
Yeah, yeah.
Graeme
Oh, he was a great disappointment to his father.
Des
Haha. I’d never even linked them before.
Judy
There was one time where he thought he might even come across and join Evan and Daryl, as it was when Graeme came across and joined them, but he, um, he wanted to go back to - I mean he wanted to stay with Oz McCutcheon - it was Planurb, was the name, or something like that, that he helped establish. [Door rings]
Des
What about James Stirling and those guys then? You said you went to England?
Evan
Yeah. We were looking at universities when we visited James Stirling.
Des
So you would have been to Oxford [Queens student housing], and Leicester [Engineering School] and...
Evan
Yes, all of those. We liked the stuff that they were doing, but it was costing a bit. Have you seen any of the editions of By Design, I think its on the ABC. In recent times they’ve been showing planning and building houses?
Jonathan
Oh, Grand Designs.
Des
I make a point of not watching it, but it is fun.
Jonathan
Unfortunately clients don’t.
Graeme
I think they lie.
Evan
They lie on the basis that they would be embarrassed about how much it really cost.
Jonathan
“It came in at about budget” As the eyes flicker.
Evan
It’s amazing. For some reason they leave the architects out. If there is mention of an architect its by and by.
Jonathan
Yes that rights - “my man”.
Des
Or else the architect comes in at an early stage and then they leave the architects behind. And then when it all goes pear-shaped - which we as architects can see coming after the credits roll - this is gonna end badly.
Evan
The guy who narrates the show is clearly an architect. But he doesn’t say so.
Judy
Is he an architect?
Bruce
Yes.
Des
Oh. He is, is he?
Graeme
They were going to have one here weren’t they.
Bruce
They have - with Peter Madison.
Des
It’s coming up. DES directed at
Evan
You know there is a local one?
Evan
Oh?
Des
A local Grand Designs show. Peter Madison is the local host.
Jonathan
Has it started being broadcast yet?
Bruce
I think so.
Judy
What’s it called?
Des
It’s called Grand Designs.
Jonathan
We were on the Discovery Channel the other day, [turns to Evan] The discovery Channel did a show on [?].
Graeme
What?
Jonathan
Rectangular Pitch. AMII Park.
Graeme
Ahh, the bubble.
Des
Did they ask the tricky question - like, “Why is the rectangular stadium made out of circles?”
Jonathan
No, no... they did ask - how much did it cost? Laughter
Evan
There was one live sort of comment where the architects had offered a rationale for an hexagonal building and he made this sound as if it was a real discovery. Certainly thought it was very clever until he started the fit out, and nothing would fit anywhere.
Graeme
I think the bees made an error of judgement on that one.
Des
Yeah, but their bums are hexagonal anyway. I always thought that the hexagon was never going to fly. If Frank Lloyd Wright couldn’t get it to work, then most of us are going to struggle. We tend to warn students off those.
Evan
To try and convince the TV viewer that something is new and different and less expensive, all the good things. That appeared on the scene and he couldn’t get the first step right- flooring company and footings that couldn’t hold the earth down. Graeme, do you - I’m starting to think - you were involved with David Yencken and the estate next to the golf course.
Graeme
Oh, Elistone. Yes.
Evan
Is that representative of another development?
Graeme
That was actually planned by Shaw with the Heidelberg Council. It was a golf estate. And he did the subdivision.
Des
Which Shaw, Graeme Shaw?
Graeme
Graeme Shaw, yeah.
Des
Is this the one that you refer to as, the Rosanna project?
Graeme
Yes, that’s Rosanna. And then Merchant Builders picked it up and introduced to this a couple of programs. One was that - well David [Yencken] said - would I be happy working with more architects? So that’s when I selected those four/three other groups - Jackson and Walker, and McGlashan Everist, and then there was Charlie Duncan. Charlie was recalcitrant. We all set off to use similar basic elements that would be put together in different ways so they would be subsequently easy to program. But Charlie nodded his head, and then went off and did his own thing. Although I must admit, Charlies things probably sold better than any of them. We bent over backwards not to be ourselves I suppose.
Jonathan
Now that’s interesting.
Graeme
Now that was one of the first developments with servicing runs underground - the lighting - David fought for that. They only did about a third of the estate when the couldn’t justify keeping it. It just wasn’t selling enough.
Des
So was that a cluster project?
Graeme
No.
Des
Cluster [housing] was Winter Park.
Graeme
It was cul de sac down to a park, and then there were a couple of manoeuvres made that sort of infiltrated and integrated the park better than normally would have happened. And then there was the first display area we did. There were two streets with two blocks of houses in it, and we hived off the centre of the blocks and made it a ‘ride’ - kept the titles retained to the boundary, but the ‘ride’ was common. And ah, that worked very well as a sort of public integration space. People used to eat there and have barbeques and stuff, and that went off to the park and went very well. I remember though, it stopped about two thirds up because one of the purchasers of the block of land said, when we suggested it to them, said, “That, that tree, this massive gum tree will be in the ride, and it’s my tree so I’m not doing it. So you can get stuffed”. Well we argued, and he just got redder and redder and he said there’s no way. So in the end that’s where the ride stopped.
Bruce
So how come it was his tree?
Graeme
Because it was on his title.
Des
So is that project the same time as City Edge?
Graeme
Oh, it could have been. Well it was the biggest project they’d done in that sense, because it didn’t have the built continuity that something like City Edge had where you just keep building. This was a planning and big landscaping program, and in fact it was all beyond Ellis Stones’ capabilities. He didn’t have anywhere near the capability to do it. So it went through, and we got Robin Edmonds over from England. He came out to run the projects.
Des
As in Maggie Edmonds Robin Edmonds?
Graeme
Yeah.
Bruce
He then went on to Hassell. He died last year.
Graeme
He fell down the stairs, as good architects do.
Evan
A stair fall was it?
Graeme
Yeah, but who was the other one that went over?
Jonathan
Burley Griffin fell off a scaffold in India.
Des
Did he?
Jonathan
Yeah, got wounded. Died of blood poisoning a couple of days later.
Graeme
Well that’s what should have happened to Ruskin too - then we wouldn’t have to read his work, ‘cause he used to do that in Venice.
Evan
[starts talking whilst Graeme talks] In India, and this building’s name was Burley Griffin one, it was Sydney Australia, but without the d.
Jonathan
Well they got it right
Des
So that where Samarance got it from then, “And the winner is.. Syney!” Hey, it’s the tenth anniversary of that.
Evan
Haha, that’s probably a good explanation of that.
Graeme
John Meyer fell over a balcony, and he died too.
Jonathan
Really? Goodness.
Des
There was a suggestion that Carlo Scarpa backed off a scaffold too, but I’m not sure if that is true.
Jonathan
Well, Gaudi certainly backed into a tram.
Des
Yeah. And they nearly killed the tram driver too, apparently. Did you hear that one? JONATHON: No. And no-one knew who he was. He died a pauper two days later at a hospital for the destitute. It wasn’t until sometime later that they realised who it was.
Des
Ah right. I thought they’d be up in arms.
Graeme
Like Louis Kahn.
Jonathan
What happened to Louis Kahn?
Judy
He was in the toilet.
Des
He was in the toilet at the station, and they didn’t know who he was.
Evan
It was two days before they found him.
Graeme
No one needed him back at the office. Laughter ensues.
Des
Well the suggestion is that Corb did the one-way swim, but I’m not sure about that. He did drown, but whether it was a suicide or not, I’m not sure. Mies - was just one too many cigars, wasn’t it?
Judy
Haha, I don’t know.
Evan
What I notice about your contribution Graeme is that - I think it was at Springvale Road, the first several blocks ...
Graeme
The Merchant Builders houses out at Springvale?
Evan
My sister brought one, and she sang the praises of it.
Graeme
Oh was that xx?
Judy
No, Camilla. But Fran - every time she sees David [Yencken] rushes up to him and says, “Oh I love that house”.
Graeme
Oh, a real romantic.
Evan
When you look at the effect that Merchant Builders had on houses.
Graeme
It was an amazing run. Well it launched my career too, I suppose. ‘Cause it was the only one ... who was the writer of the Home Beautiful? Eric Wilson? He used to splash it around all of the time.
Judy
But there was nothing else here. I remember coming back from Canada and looking around. I mean, there was cream brick veneer for miles.
Graeme
Jennings had it all.
Judy
But then these wonderful little gems started appearing - which was in a language that I certainly was familiar with having grown up on the west coast of Canada - you know, wood, glass, lovely proportions and what have you. It was very exciting.
Evan
Who had the first house?
Graeme
I think Peter Hollingworth had the first house.
Judy
Did he? Where? In Fitzroy?
Graeme
No. In Glen Waverley.
Judy
I think it’s Doctor Peter Hollingworth now.
Des
But wasn’t he a priest?
Judy
Hahah. Yes he was. He was an archbishop as well!
Bruce
What inspired David Yencken?
Graeme
Well, we, inspired each other. I hadn’t met David until I was at Robin Boyd’s, and he was doing the Black Dolphin. And the last bit was being done when I was in the office, and David came down and I just met him briefly. And then we all travelled by plane once - the [Roy] Grounds office - to Canberra, Merriumbula, and then to Canberra with Allan Nelson. He was a part of Roy’s offsider. I met David again, and then I didn’t see him for a while. And I didn’t have any work and thought I better do something positive, so I started Chinese. Harry Simons had started a course in Melbourne. And there was David - he was doing Chinese because when he sold his first motel he went to Hong Kong for five months and had a knowledge of Chinese Mandarin. So we met and we had lunch - a couple of lunches - and we talked about housing. And he said well, the fact that you couldn’t get well designed housing at a reasonable costs and not have to pay the architects fees - which were pretty onerous for a lot of people. I mean, you still can’t borrow the fees for architecture. You can borrow fees for construction, but not the fees for architecture, unless you do something clever. And so he said “When I’ve sold the Black Dolphin” - which was up for sale then - “I’ll have some money and we’ll start it”. I didn’t think it would happen but it did. Then I didn’t think it would happen because when I signed the contract for royalties - I was reasonably naive. I didn’t have a lawyer, hadn’t seen a lawyer, I don’t think I had a bank at that time... [Laughter] So I said to David, “Can I use your lawyer?”, and he said, “I don’t think that’s a very good idea” [Laughter]. But anyway, we did, and I signed the royalty agreement for five years. And of course it went for about twenty years or more. And Jonny Ridge, who was a very lovely fellow and always very fair and he on his side erred on his balance sheet. And he said “No, that’s the end of the contract. Five years. You don’t get any more royalties”.
Des
I don’t think that’s erring... I think that’s -
Graeme
He was very philosophical about it when I raised it with him.
Jonathan
Did you become philosophical about it too?
Graeme
No, I didn’t. I’d moved on... in fact after about ten years I’d had enough of houses.
Evan
When we were involved, though association with John Button and...
Des
As in senator John Button?
Graeme
Yeah. He was one of the Hawthorn Labour pusch. He lived over here.
Evan
There’s a sequence of contacts you can trace pretty much. Architects who were doing their best to build good houses with no money. Button got involved because of a book...
Graeme
“Look Here!”
Evan
“Look Here!”
Graeme
With Bruce Weatherhead, they rampaged around the state, didn’t they?
Jonathan
Who put that book together?
Evan
Jackson, it was a ... was your name on it? [Talking to Graeme]
Graeme
No, I don’t think so.
Bruce
“Look Here!”?
Des
With the broken bottle on the cover?
Evan
Yeah. The broken bottle. The beer bottle. GRAEME and
Judy
Daryl [Jackson] wasn’t involved with that.
Bruce
Yeah, I think Daryl is in it.
Evan
Daryl was certainly involved.
Judy
It was a series of essays, wasn’t it?
Des
Yeah. My memory says that Daryl’s name is on the cover. But I remember the broken beer bottle. I’ve still got it. Not the broken beer bottle...
Evan
It had visual impact. Sold pretty well. It was a book about design.
Graeme
When it came out, there was another book at the time too.
Des
It was also a social book, wasn’t it?
Evan
Yes.
Des
It was about the confluence between social structures and events, and how the design of the environment could make that better, that’s what I ... that’s what my memory says it was about.
Evan
Well that’s a pretty good memory. That’s what it was.
Des
I just remember the broken beer bottle cause it seemed to be anathema to the content of it.
Graeme
Well Bruce Weatherhead - he and Button got on very well. Strangely enough ‘cause Bruce doesn’t have a great social conscience. And they shared a farm together up at Woodend -he and Button - so they must have had something in their personalities that linked them. In fact Bruce, who is still, still there, but he lives in a Housing Commission house down in Dreyden or something, um -
Evan
Does that suggest that life has got pretty tough?
Graeme
He hasn’t done anything for years. When computers came in he ran away.
Judy
That was it. Had a big effect, didn’t it.
Graeme
Couldn’t accept that you had to use them.
Judy
Do you remember they started the Fun Factory over here in Richmond.
Graeme
Yeah, that’s right.
Judy
Which was brilliant. I mean it was absolutely brilliant.
Graeme
That was ‘Jigsaw’, that was.
Judy
That’s it!
Des
Who started that? JUDY and
Graeme
Alex Stitt and Bruce.
Graeme
They were partners then. They fell out when they brought the big house down here.
Judy
And swapped their wives didn’t they? They were a very exciting pair, though, I mean really ...
Evan
We would run into them at the RMIT. They were art students, both of them. They were doing knockout stuff.
Graeme
But Bruce said on that trip - when they did the Look Here! Trip, he and Button - it was Button’s job to find the nurses at every stop. He would ring up and... He said he was pretty good at that.
Des
But John Button was a federal politician?
Judy
Yes.
Des
Ok, so did that give people a foray into federal work, or not necessarily? If John Button was a federal politician at that stage, did that link Victorian architects with federal or national work? Did that happen?
Judy
No.
Evan
It’s always always really ‘work to get work’. The relationship between the best architects in Victoria and the National Capital Development Committee [NCDC] is remarkably close.
Judy
But I don’t think the link was John, because I think probably where John was more powerful was his personal influence on people. For instance, he was the one that took ... when we first got back we met John at David Yencken’s place, and you were probably there that night [gestures to Graeme], there was a dinner party in 1969, just as we got back. And Button approached Evan and said, “I understand that you are interested in politics” because we had been involved in politics in Toronto in Canada during the [Pierre] Trudeaux era, which was a very exciting time in Canada. In fact our lawyer actually ran Trudeaux’s national campaign, so we were very involved - right in the key of it - and one of Evan’s very best friends from his days when he was a student at the university of Toronto, became the national secretary for the Liberal Party. Now the Liberal Party isn’t like the Liberal Party here. Anyway it’s left of centre. So we were very involved in the heavy stuff of what he could do and change and that sort of thing. So we came to Australia and Evan had made it very clear from the beginning that he wanted to get involved in politics and it would be Labor. And when John heard this - I think David probably told him - he approached Evan and said, “where do you live?” and Evan said “Hawthorn”, and John said, “Well come with me”. And so Evan became a member of the Hawthorn branch of the Labor Party within months after we arrived. And it was John Button. But he influenced a lot of people. He influenced a whole generation. I mean you and ...
Evan
Yes, he was much admired.
Judy
Much admired, and much loved.
Des
What’s his background? JUDY and
Evan
Lawyer.
Graeme
He was ‘Morris Blackburn’.
Evan
We should say that he died two years ago.
Des
Yeah, He is May’s father in law
Judy
May?
Des
You know May Lam?
Judy
Oh yes, I know May. She’s wonderful! How do you know May?
Des
oh um... my first real girlfriend was May’s sister...
Judy
Oh right!
Des
So I’ve known May for years...
Evan
[Unknown comment from Evan]
Judy
But that’s an interesting story, too. But I think it’s true. I think John’s influence and interest was always in design. He spent some time in Perugia learning Italian. So he wasn’t just a lawyer and a politician, he was a writer and a thinker.
Des
See I’ve never heard John Button’s name associated in these conversations before, so this is quite new for me. Any of the other characters you speak of, I have kind of heard of, but I didn’t know John Button was in that mix at all. ‘Cause this is pre-Whitlam? JUDY and
Evan
Yes.
Des
‘Cause Button was a Whitlam minister?
Graeme
Yeah. He had some great stories about Whitlam.
Evan
Now with Button the Whitlam phenomena got going. Another piece of information about Button was that he was at the heart of the intervention in trying to get rid of Bill Hartly.
Judy
The ‘faceless men’.
Graeme
Bill Hayden or Bill Hartly?
Judy
Bill Hartly. Early on. We’re talking really early on.
Graeme
And Bill Hayden as well?
Judy
Eventually, yes.
Des
Bill Hartly is a union man, have I got the right person?
Graeme
Yes, he was.
Evan
That was when he manufactured a series of major conferences - a few meetings at St Kilda town hall. He had the capacity to basically make changes. He made the Labor party worth belonging to.
Des
I think I have read some of this stuff in [Graeme]Freudenberg’s biography. Have I got the right character? Mark Freudenberg was the speech writer?
Judy
Yes. He was ‘the’ speech writer. Well we came home just at the end, just as that movement had formed, and got the energy and impact from it. We came home in ’69 from Canada, so of course, it was just the right time to get involved.
Des
So that’s the run that Gough didn’t win? Cause he won in ’72.
Judy
Yes, he won ’72.
Evan
But he won more seats ...
Judy
It was Bill ...
Graeme
We don’t talk about those things these days. [Laughter]
Des
Did he win more seats in ’69?
Jonathan
Got more of the popular vote?
Evan
Ahh, actually, it sort of happens more than once. If you look at the Victorian tickets for the ’70 Victorian state election, Labor was leading, or at least that’s what we thought.
Graeme
That’s probably a blessing though..
Judy
Anyway, we’re off the topic though.
Evan
Bloody memory. Let’s you down just when you need it.
Graeme
But Button was interested in talking about very personalised discussions. He would be at you all the time. Talking and then...
Des
He was obviously putting lots of stuff together.
Graeme
He had lots of mannerisms in his whole body movement, that if you walked down the street he was telling you a story.“Yes John”, and if somebody in front of you stopped you’d have to [claps hands] stop! - so he’d finish the punch line. The one story that stood out to me though, was he was bitching with Gough in Cabinet, and Gough was dismissive of what he was trying to get up, “Forget about it!” Button said, “I have to keep going on this, I’ve gotta get it.” So when the Cabinet meeting finished, he said “I waited down the hall and sprang out at Gough as he came down the hall, just to get him and make this point.” And Gough just swept him aside and said “Get out of my way you fucking little cunt”. [Laughter]
Evan
Beautiful language!
Evan
They had - it was a conference, a Labor Party conference - it was an important one. At the end of the day, on Thursday, he [Button] went back to his office. He was working away, when there was a knock on the door. This is the Old Parliament House. The doors were stippled glass, and there John always claimed he was frightened of Gough. Anyway, I knocked on the door and there was a scuffle in the office and then quiet. It was obvious that someone was trying to get out of the way. So I went back to the senate office and said there is no one there. Anyway, when I went back Button was kneeling on the floor behind the desk. He looked up over the desk and said, “Oh, it’s you.” And I said, “Well, where’d you appear from?” And he said, “You have the same silhouette as a certain large gentleman”.... [Laughter]
Judy
Oh, he was hiding under the desk.
Graeme
Well that’s interesting. He had a propensity to do that because, do you remember the Last Laugh? EVAN and
Judy
Oh yes.
Judy
Oh yes, these boys, they’ve got to hear this story.
Jonathan
Oh yes, tell us please.
Des
Is this the Last Laugh meeting?
Judy
Yes.
Evan
There are several stories.
Graeme
Well, John was under the table that night.
Des
So was he at the Last Laugh? The famous ‘carafe pitching’ Last Laugh?
Graeme
He was there. He was at the head table.
Judy
He was one of the ones that was brought into the be the kind of... Renata How was there, she was the historian.
Graeme
Was she there?
Judy
Yes she was. She never forgot it.
Evan
She was billed, she made a paper.
Judy
She delivered a paper.
Graeme
Really?
Judy
I remember Evan coming home after and just telling me about this.
Graeme
Was he able to speak?
Judy
He wasn’t to start with, he was white faced and you know. And then, you know, as he started to tell me, it got funnier and funnier and funnier. I mean you had to - it was just outrageous!
Evan
Not to say, we were very sorry about Bill Corker, who happened to get in the way of a glass carafe.
Judy
He almost got killed!
Graeme
A missile.
Evan
Those carafes are very ...
Judy
Heavy.
Graeme
It was a very bad throw, actually.
Evan
Yeah. It was a very bad throw.
Bruce
It was probably empty, too.
Judy
How did John Button introduce?
Graeme
I don’t know whether John was the chairman, or if Andrew was supposed to be the chairman. You started it all, because we had that office opening at Shellier Street up here in Richmond, our new office. And we had a number of architects then, and it was the first time that there had been that sort of grouping of ...
Bruce
I knew that. I’ve been to Shellier Street a few times. I wasn’t at the Last Laugh.
Graeme
No this was the opening. We had the bankers one evening, and then the architects another evening. And then you said after that - ‘cause everyone got on very well - “why don’t we work on the others in architecture”. Like Noel Logan the geographer, and people like that, and possibly Button was there, “why don’t we get together and start to work something out, a strategy for dealing with Melbourne”.
Evan
It was going very well.
Graeme
It was going to be a new way of approaching Melbourne’s development. And it was about ideas, and so we had a big list. And I think Corrigan, Norman Day and myself drew up the list. But you said, let’s do it, and ... ahh, even the AR were there. So they were there in the cloisters, in the Gods. They were a bit shocked.
Des
Was that Rory Spence, or someone else?
Graeme
Oh, I forget who it was. But it fell about in the so called debate. That’s when it started. Corrigan’s actual physical expression of the angst that developed was another thing. But the debate got off the rails between Bernie Joyce and Kevin Borland and Corrigan, probably. So there was a group talking about, and this was the objective, to talk about the broader issues and what we might do, and how you might develop strategies. And I think it was Bernie and Kevin got going on the basis of design, and good design was the only thing that mattered. By that ... at that age we’d all seen the social issues as perhaps more than the design issues. It was very heavily influenced by this lot, talking about social matters. So we were vulnerable in that sense, and I think that is where it really got off the rails.
Evan
A wonderful phrase when Button was talking about Peter Corrigan...
Graeme
Oh, that’s it - the morbid little lepricorn....
Judy
Oh no... morbid... Irish.... oh, melancholy!
Evan
Melancholy Irish Mystic! [Laughter]
Des
Is Corrigan left wing leaning or is he a right wing guy.
Graeme
Oh. I don’t know if he is either...
Judy
I don’t think you could classify him...
Des
I hadn’t thought of it before, and just when you were putting Kevin and Bernie Joyce together, ‘cause Kevin was probably still a card holding member of the Communist Party by then, and Bernie Joyce I imagine was probably pretty leftish... or certainly on the ratbag fringe? And Corrigan, I don’t know.
Evan
He loved a shouting match. It was a long long throw.
Des
But who was Corrigan throwing it at?
Graeme
Bernie.
Des
Ohh. He was throwing it at Bernie Joyce.
Evan
Corrigan had names for everybody.
Graeme
So did Bernie. Bernie had the names.
Evan
It was terrific. We had to really never do it again. People saw the chance about reactivating what was going to be, or could have been, a very important moment. But it stopped dead in its tracks.
Des
Well, I’m pretty sure I was working for Max at the time, Max May, and I had, I must have just ... when was it ’78 or something?
Graeme
Ah, yep.
Evan
‘bout then.
Des
‘Bout then, ‘cause in ’77 I worked for Kevin. I was in my year out for Kevin and then I remember I was at Max’s office. And Max came in - I must have been at work the day after, I still remember really vividly - Max coming in and saying about this thing at the Last Laugh, and he was really annoyed that this incredible opportunity had just being pissed up against the wall by Corrigan throwing a carafe at someone, and the whole thing dissolving. I just remember Max saying it was an embarrassingly wasted opportunity for us as architects to have a real...
Graeme
Well, it was as if there was a big pile of rats there, and a big pile of food, and instead of eating the food they ate themselves. It was mortifying. I remember David Yencken rang me two days later saying, “You’ve got to get it going again before it goes off the boil. The idea is great”. And I said, “No, I’m not doing that again”.
Des
Well that’s what struck me, cause Max was hardly ever animated about collective operations. He’s a bit of a loner, anyway. But I still remember it so vividly, him coming in and going, “We had this amazing opportunity with all these people basically on the same side, with lots of different interests, and then it just fell apart in a drunken mix up”. And he was so annoyed.
Judy
That’s so embarrassing.
Evan
You would think we were all sensible people.
Judy
Well you had other people that weren’t architects involved, and that’s what was so -
Des
Well, I think that was what Max was also thinking, because he said the profession just looked ...
Judy
So terrible. [Laughter]
Evan
There was another important sequence which was Graeme involved in. You asked me to be chair in the RMIT faculty meeting at Inverloch.
Graeme
When I went to RMIT. That’s right.
Des
And when was that?
Graeme
That’s ’72.
Des
Ok .... It must have been time Graeme
Graeme
Hmm?
Jonathan
‘It’s time’.
Graeme
How do you mean? JONATHAN and
Des
That was Gough’s slogan in ’72.
Graeme
Oh was it? Oh well it wasn’t long before he was out. And I interviewed all the staff and got through that, ‘cause they knew nothing about education, or the system, or the process of what monies they had anyway. So I thought I better start at the basics. At the grassroots level, and it occurred to me then that the only way to get this group, which I didn’t have a lot of time. To all go away together and have some key people - and Evan was one of them - to come down. Were you on the council then?
Evan
You put me there.
Graeme
You were on the council, yeah.
Evan
So, Iwas in my first year.
Graeme
So we had a facilitator, and we had Barry McNeil who was the guru in education. Barry was a great devotee of all of the good thinking at the time. So he was very helpful. And we went to this place which is about one hundred and fifty years old.
Jonathan
Whereabouts?
Graeme
Inverloch. It’s no longer there which is - probably just dissipated into a pile of dust. In fact I worked on it about three years ago with a developer, so there’s nothing there. It was the Inverloch motel. And we couldn’t pay so it was the cheapest thing we could find. But that was what got RMIT going - that little coffin.
Evan
It was a good start for you, because they saw it. Being taken in and around and with various people. It gave them good confidence.
Graeme
Yeah, ‘cause there was, they were all entrenched, as you know, in their own pockets. And it seemed a good way to re-energize it. Get them to forget what they were doing and somehow get together. An example was Ron Centum. Ron was a guy who had lectured us when we were students back in the ‘50s early to mid 50s. And Ron was on the perch by this time. And they used to go - the orientation week was when the teachers would go away. Peter Wilson, Ron and another couple of them and they’d say, “Alright, here’s the camp”. They’d all go up to the pub, and, ah they’d been doing this for years. But this particular year two students objected to this and came to see me and said, “We are fling a complaint”. And I said to Peter Wilson, “you know this is a problem. Um, I am going to have to report Ron Centum”. And he said “You can’t do that”, he went off, and he came back and, “I had to take a pill” he said, “this is very upsetting”. I could see that. I didn’t know what to do in the end so I decided that I would get Ron in and talk to him and just go over it. I said “This isn’t good” and he stuttered and that sort of thing. “We’ve been doing this .... and it’s not bad it’s... and you can’t do anything anyway”. And I said, “Well, what I would advise you to do is get hold of the students and meet them and talk to them about it”. And he did. He got them out to his place, and his wife was a beautiful woman I think, and they all had a talk, and he came back and he said they said it’s all fixed. They all understood where they were at and then at this conference there was Ron with his arm up going “Go, go, we’re going for the students”. He was very revolutionary.
Evan
That’s fantastic.
Des
Are you an RMIT graduate?
Evan
Yeah.
Des
And is Daryl[Jackson]?
Evan
Yeah.
Judy
As well as [Melbourne] University, because it was during that period of time that you couldn’t actually get a degree from RMIT, so you had to finish it at Melbourne. Is that right? So they were really products of both.
Evan
Except....
Graeme
No, you got a diploma. But you do the three year full-time, and the three years part-time.
Evan
They thought you could get credits for your three years at RMIT, plus the university said that in the fourth year you would have to have two more subjects. The best subjects I ever did at Melbourne University was Fine Arts with Sarah Berry[?] and Bernard Smith.
Graeme
And Patrick [McCaughey] would’ve not been there then, would he?
Evan
No. Patrick jumped off between.... Daryl and... we did two possibly two and a half extra subjects. And we worked up ourselves because it was made very clear that tech end of things, that we wouldn’t be allowed to get a xxx are far as we weren’t going to work hard. And, it ended up with Lewis, Prof. [Brian]Lewis getting pretty pissed off with about half a dozen tech students that made the transfer and topped the.... we filled places one, two, four and five. And that was very critical frame. Prof. Lewis didn’t like it. He [wanted his] students taking out the prizes. As a matter of fact the fourth year prize was awarded to ... ahh. the prof’s niece. And she got the 500 quid! And I had a stern word with head of the Hopkins award for fourth year. “How come the award went to a person who wasn’t anywhere near a top student. If you’re gonna have top students”. And he said, he described his style, he said “She’s gonna get married and she needs the money”.
Des
Well things haven’t changed.
Jonathan
Brutal honesty.
Graeme
Nothing like that participants, if you’re on the receiving end.
Evan
Now the set of Professor .... six months later in June the following year, we get a phone call saying there’s something out. I forget the words, ‘there’s a piece of paper on my desk, the prize monies, to the person allocated who was finishing in the fifth year’.
Graeme
So you got the prize money for that?
Evan
There were two prizes, I got the lesser one.
Graeme
But yours was invested for six months before you got it?
Evan
Yes.
Des
Did you say the Picton Hopkins Prize? Are they the plaster people? So they handed out one of the architecture prizes?
Evan
Yes. It was worth a lot. I thought it was worth a crack to beat Jackson.
Graeme
Well you were a year ahead of me. I was a year later.
Evan
You were with Bill Ryan.
Graeme
Yes. We were, what do you call them, mature aged students. We were 22 when we started.
Evan
Both of you had done quite a lot of building.
Graeme
Yeah, Bill was a more refined expert than I.
Jonathan
Well he was a carpenter.
Graeme
Yeah, well, my father was a builder and I spent six years, but I mostly drove the truck. I didn’t like carpentry.
Des
You didn’t like?
Graeme
Nup.
Evan
Didn’t you have your uncle or something?
Graeme
It was my father. The whole family are builders going back to, ugh, 1850.
Evan
So when you appeared at the RMIT you were older than us?
Graeme
Mmm, well I was 22, so.
Evan
And you had your ticket in carpentry.
Graeme
And I had to matriculate there at RMIT. They had a prelim year in those days, where you did nine subjects, and then to continue.
Jonathan
Bit of an introduction, isn’t it!
Des
Yeah, we used to do many more than the students do now.
Graeme
I remember we had to do chemistry, physics, as well and maths 2B. B was the calculus, which I never did and never have done. And with chemistry that year I decided after a while I wasn’t going to be able to get there with that either. And just on the night of the exam, by that time we were into the ... we’d been pill popping, not for recreation purposes, for work purposes to keep awake. Bentadine. Truck drivers used it anyway. So I decided to strategize this exam - went through the old papers, decided there was about 30% that had a good chance of coming up again and stayed up all night and went over that 30%. And that was my first take, and I got 50% for that.
Evan
That’s a fairly indefinite result.
Bruce
It could have meant you got 46%...
Des
I was just going to go there...
Graeme
They heaved me over the line, ‘we don’t want him back here, get him outta here’. [Laughter]
Des
That’s cool. Well we have probably annoyed you enough for one day Evan.
Evan
I have enjoyed it, I can’t imagine it’s of any use.
Des
Oh, it’s fantastic.
Evan
I am actually writing, I began a year ago, a diary from memory. In other words, a sort of comment or story that we were talking about today.
Graeme
Is that coming off well?
Evan
Well I am still working on, I am using that device, it’s what they call ... it records and gives you a typed copy.
Graeme
And that works?
Evan
Yeah. So far it has worked very well.
Bruce
Oh, yeah. Recognises your voice?
Evan
I sort of decided that I didn’t want to just have a diary. I find it’s best to tell stories as you are going along so you can take side roads, and tell stories you probably enjoy. So thank you.
Des
That’s exactly the intention of these ones.
Judy
Oh, they should continue!
Jonathan
Is there a good afternoon?
Des
Well, if you’d like. ‘Cause I’d like to have another conversation. What we have done is we’ve scribbled up some notes, and you know you can have a look through them. And that’s the list of people that we would like to talk to. There are some questions here that we thought we might run past people, so you and Evan might want to look through them, and then if you want to have another chat with us ...
Judy
Have you spoken to Daryl [Jackson]?
Des
No. Well Daryl has already been done.
Jonathan
What we thought we would talk about is the people that haven’t been so published, or at the forefront of self-promotion.
Judy
Oh, I see. [Laughter]
Jonathan
If people have done books and...
Judy
Oh, how beautiful.
Jonathan
You know what I mean?
Judy
I do, But it would be interesting to see the interaction though... I don’t think he was at that Last Laugh was he?
Graeme
Oh yeah.
Evan
He was. He was at our table.
Jonathan
He emptied the carafe before it got thrown.
Judy
I never think of Daryl as being there. But yeah, I think it’s a very good idea!
Jonathan
So we thought we would focus more on people like Bill Ryan, for example.
Judy
Oh Billy, very important.
Evan
He is a good and lovely guy. He has great stories.
Des
Well he is on our list.
Jonathan
I am sure that every time we speak to someone there will be more names that come forward. So look, we have put some questions down.
Evan
I’ll have a look.
Judy
It’s a pity Jamie’s not around, we miss him too. Jamie Learmoth.
Des
Ah, yeah.
Evan
He doesn’t have the tech component.
Jonathan
What tech component?
Judy
Came through the tech [RMIT].
Jonathan
No, that’s not a filter of ours.
Evan
No, but the stories are better.
Judy
This just shows Evan’s filters, bias. All the tech boys that were so badly dealt with at the university.
Evan
It was coming to, a very lovely piece about Harry Winbush. I have to say I misunderstood him. He was instrumental in levering people like Graeme Gunn and Bill Ryan. He certainly helped me.
Judy
[Evan Walker]
Graeme
It’s interesting ‘cause when I went there, I just came down without any plan. And I just rolled up at RMIT and said I wanted to do Architecture and saw Harry. All we had then was the Taylor[?] book, which was a little book they put out for university subject entrants. That’s all I ever had, so I got this. Knew I couldn’t get into Melbourne University. I didn’t have any money anyway, so went to see him. There was Harry sitting behind this column in his office. And me sort of doing this, and said, “I want to do part-time architecture”. And he said “You can’t”, and I said “Well I need to ‘cause I don’t - I need to get a job and work during the day”. And he said, “No. You can’t do it”. And I found out later you could do it.
Evan
But you gained marks for perseverance.
Graeme
And I said that stuffs that, and I walked around the city for about two hours. And I went back in the afternoon and it wasn’t him then, it was Max Freeland, and I said “I’ve decided to do full-time”, and he said “Good. Good luck”. So that was Harry. If it wasn’t for Harry I’d probably still be walking those streets.
Graeme
I must go. We should do it again. Goodbyes ensue.
Des
So if you have a look through the questions and what we’ve said, and if you’d like to do it again we might roll into some of those.
Judy
Lovely idea to have Bill Ryan because he is an observer. He has been the classic observer, and he doesn’t miss anything, and he would be good for the interactions too.
Evan
We see a lot of him. I started a painting group.
Des
Ah yes, that’s right. I had heard about that. Lygon Street?
Judy
No. They paint over here. Just upstairs. Evans: When I started it there was lots of room.
Judy
Pete Sanders and Evan, and Andy McChuteon, and Andrew Begg[?]. And then you’ve got Ian Cunningham who is a medico and Barry Pullen is an engineer, who was also Minister for Housing in the government. So you’ve got the architects and the ...
Jonathan
There was some interesting graffiti in that period too. [Indescribable line about “Pullen”.] [Laughter]
Des
That’s a very distinct memory you’ve got there.
Judy
Yeah, I love it.
Jonathan
A car named desire, or a street named desire was another one, too.
Judy
But this was an interesting conversation listening to today. I don’t know how you felt about this Bruce, but Graeme was such a central part of the design in that early [period], wasn’t he Evan? He was such an important designer. Very. I remember how you deferred to Graeme and his wonderful aesthetic sense. And he came and made ... and he didn’t have all the privileges and opportunities that people have today, and he made a huge contribution. And it was nice to hear him talk today.
Des
Well that’s why Graeme is on our list, but that’s also why we had the initial conversation with Graeme to see if he thought it was a cool idea. Ah, and then he was interested to come and talk with Evan and a few of the others. And the whole idea, as you’ve spotted, is that’s it’s actually supposed to be a conversation - the history and it’s value.
Judy
It emerges.
Des
And again it’s interesting that the last ... ‘cause I think Evan brought up the Last Laugh issue. And that came up talking to Graeme, and now I’ve found out that it involves more and more.
Jonathan
John Button and others. Extraordinary.
Judy
I thought it was also you guys’ attempt to refocus the Institute [RAIA], and try and make the Institute more relevant as well.
Evan
We have special ... Phill McCloud came down and talked.
Judy
He was a psychiatrist. He got a psychiatrist involved.
Jonathan
Well, he would have had plenty of raw material.
Judy
He still shakes his head about it.
Jonathan
It’s a history of the Last Laugh night. We’ll need a re-enactment.
Evan
He said, he was a psychiatrist with a difference. We spent three nights with his before planning it. Reg Grouse?
Judy
He was great. He was the president of the iInstitute, and we arrived in Australia.
Des
And this is why it’s a conversation, ‘cause it goes like this.
Jonathan
It’s as much to do with the matrix as it is with any one of the threads.
Judy
Oh, it’s good!
Jonathan
So we can say that that was Evan and Judy Walker?
Judy
No, no just say Evan.
Jonathan
And Graeme Gunn, Des Smith, Bruce Allen, and Jonathan Gardiner on the 15th of September 2010, which is the Battle of Britain date for those that remember.
Des
And the tenth anniversary of the start of the Sydney Olympics.
Jonathan
And how many sleeping nights until the Delhi games?